Omar Cabrera, Christopher Brown
Texto del documento (el modelo recibió exactamente este texto)
Project Team Meeting Minutes – Austin Office Date: March 12, 2025, 9:00–10:30 AM Location: Conference Room C202 Attendees: Jimmy Davies, Omar Cabrera, Christopher Brown Minutes taken by: Omar Cabrera Pages: 4 Agenda: 1. Marketing campaign 2. Office remodel 3. Schedule 4. Action items Jimmy Davies opened the meeting, welcomed everyone and gave a brief update on the project. The project is on track; the only delays concern deliveries. 1. Marketing campaign Omar Cabrera proposed setting aside $66,000 for the fall marketing campaign, arguing that the scope has grown since the original brief. Jimmy Davies pointed out that the project budget cannot absorb that much. The proposal of $66,000 was rejected in a vote (2 for, 5 against). The team then approved $50,000 for the fall marketing campaign. 2. Office remodel Christopher Brown presented quotes from three vendors and recommended the best value. For comparison, the same item cost $23,000 last year. The team approved $33,000 for remodeling the second-floor offices. 3. Schedule The original deadline for the interim report, May 16, 2025, cannot be met because the numbers from accounting are still missing. The team agreed on a new deadline of June 7, 2025; the original date of May 16, 2025 no longer applies. All other dates remain unchanged. Omar Cabrera noted that the affected departments need to be informed of the change. 4. Action items - Omar Cabrera: prepare the interim report for senior management, due June 7, 2025 - Christopher Brown: prepare and sign the vendor contract, due April 3, 2025 Next meeting: March 19, 2025, same room. Please send any corrections to these minutes within two business days.
Veredicto
El más barato sin errores: Mistral Small 4, a 0,11 € por cada 1000 documentos.
- Mistral Large 4 tampoco comete errores, pero es 55,8× más caro.
Prompt enviado a todos los modelos
Summarize the document below (meeting minutes, a project status report or an email thread) in at
most 80 words.
Rules:
- Include every final decision: the approved amounts, the deadlines that apply and the people
responsible for the action items (full names).
- Do not mention rejected proposals or their amounts, and do not mention deadlines that were
changed (the original dates); state only the deadlines that apply.
- Copy amounts and dates exactly as in the document; do not round them.
- Write in the language of the document, factually and in a formal register, as running text
without headings.
- Return only JSON in the form {"summary": "…"}.
Cómo puntuamos
Coincidencia exacta por campo tras normalizar fechas, importes y espacios. La falta de diacríticos cuenta como error. El coste es el gasto real en tokens de esta ejecución, convertido al tipo de cambio indicado en el pie de página.
Lo que extrajo cada modelo
| Campo | Valor correcto | Mistral Small 46 / 6 campos | Gemma 4 31B6 / 6 campos | GPT-6 Luna6 / 6 campos | Claude Haiku 5.56 / 6 campos | Gemini 3.5 Flash Lite6 / 6 campos | Qwen3.8 Flash6 / 6 campos | DeepSeek V4.1 Flash6 / 6 campos | GLM-5.3 Flash6 / 6 campos | Mistral Medium 3.56 / 6 campos | Claude Sonnet 5.56 / 6 campos | Claude Sonnet 56 / 6 campos | GPT-6 Sol6 / 6 campos | Gemini 3.8 Flash6 / 6 campos | Mistral Large 46 / 6 campos |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Importes | 50000.0; 33000.0 | 50000; 33000 (correcto) | 50000; 33000 (correcto) | 50000; 33000 (correcto) | 50000; 33000 (correcto) | 50000; 33000 (correcto) | 50000; 33000 (correcto) | 50000; 33000 (correcto) | 50000; 33000 (correcto) | 50000; 33000 (correcto) | 50000; 33000 (correcto) | 50000; 33000 (correcto) | 50000; 33000 (correcto) | 50000; 33000 (correcto) | 50000; 33000 (correcto) |
| Plazos | 2025-06-07; 2025-04-03 | 2025-06-07; 2025-04-03 (correcto) | 2025-06-07; 2025-04-03 (correcto) | 2025-06-07; 2025-04-03 (correcto) | 2025-06-07; 2025-04-03 (correcto) | 2025-06-07; 2025-04-03 (correcto) | 2025-06-07; 2025-04-03 (correcto) | 2025-06-07; 2025-04-03 (correcto) | 2025-06-07; 2025-04-03 (correcto) | 2025-06-07; 2025-04-03 (correcto) | 2025-06-07; 2025-04-03 (correcto) | 2025-06-07; 2025-04-03 (correcto) | 2025-06-07; 2025-04-03 (correcto) | 2025-06-07; 2025-04-03 (correcto) | 2025-06-07; 2025-04-03 (correcto) |
| Responsables | Omar Cabrera; Christopher Brown | Omar Cabrera; Christopher Brown (correcto) | Omar Cabrera; Christopher Brown (correcto) | Omar Cabrera; Christopher Brown (correcto) | Omar Cabrera; Christopher Brown (correcto) | Omar Cabrera; Christopher Brown (correcto) | Omar Cabrera; Christopher Brown (correcto) | Omar Cabrera; Christopher Brown (correcto) | Omar Cabrera; Christopher Brown (correcto) | Omar Cabrera; Christopher Brown (correcto) | Omar Cabrera; Christopher Brown (correcto) | Omar Cabrera; Christopher Brown (correcto) | Omar Cabrera; Christopher Brown (correcto) | Omar Cabrera; Christopher Brown (correcto) | Omar Cabrera; Christopher Brown (correcto) |
| Propuestas rechazadas (no deben aparecer)Importes de propuestas que el documento rechaza. No deben aparecer en el resumen: confundirían al lector. | 66000.0 | — (correcto) | — (correcto) | — (correcto) | — (correcto) | — (correcto) | — (correcto) | — (correcto) | — (correcto) | — (correcto) | — (correcto) | — (correcto) | — (correcto) | — (correcto) | — (correcto) |
| Plazos sustituidos (no deben aparecer)Fechas que el documento cambia más adelante. El resumen solo debe dar la nueva fecha. | 2025-05-16 | — (correcto) | — (correcto) | — (correcto) | — (correcto) | — (correcto) | — (correcto) | — (correcto) | — (correcto) | — (correcto) | — (correcto) | — (correcto) | — (correcto) | — (correcto) | — (correcto) |
| Longitud (máx. palabras)El resumen no puede superar el límite de palabras del prompt. | 80 | 44 / 80 (correcto) | 53 / 80 (correcto) | 54 / 80 (correcto) | 56 / 80 (correcto) | 56 / 80 (correcto) | 52 / 80 (correcto) | 50 / 80 (correcto) | 78 / 80 (correcto) | 39 / 80 (correcto) | 56 / 80 (correcto) | 72 / 80 (correcto) | 68 / 80 (correcto) | 51 / 80 (correcto) | 52 / 80 (correcto) |
| Tokens | entrada / salida | 585 / 81 | 597 / 95 | 567 / 195 | 1026 / 132 | 585 / 96 | 709 / 679 | 619 / 492 | 553 / 1020 | 585 / 74 | 1026 / 130 | 1024 / 171 | 567 / 299 | 585 / 1253 | 582 / 2971 |
| de ellos, razonamiento oculto | se factura como salida | 0 | 0 | 102 | 0 | 0 | 579 | 410 | 903 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 190 | 1165 | 2635 |
| de ellos, desde caché | entrada con descuento | 133 | 3 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Coste de este documento | esta ejecución | 0,0001 € | 0,0001 € | 0,0001 € | 0,0002 € | 0,0004 € | 0,0004 € | 0,0004 € | 0,0005 € | 0,0013 € | 0,0031 € | 0,0035 € | 0,0038 € | 0,0047 € | 0,0061 € |
| Por cada 1000 documentos | para el mismo tipo de documento | 0,11 € | 0,11 € | 0,14 € | 0,16 € | 0,38 € | 0,39 € | 0,42 € | 0,55 € | 1,32 € | 3,08 € | 3,46 € | 3,79 € | 4,73 € | 6,08 € |
| Latencia | esta ejecución | 0,8 s | 2,7 s | 2,7 s | 1,8 s | 0,9 s | 9 s | 5,5 s | 6,9 s | 0,8 s | 1,8 s | 2,3 s | 7,2 s | 5,3 s | 35 s |