Heather Butler, April Cuevas, Terry Ramos
Document text (the model received exactly this text)
From: Terry Ramos <terry.ramos@barton.example> Date: July 31, 2025 Subject: ERP Upgrade – budget and dates Hi all, Here is my proposal for the next phase of ERP Upgrade. The scope has grown since the original brief, so I suggest setting aside $5,500 for the fall marketing campaign. For comparison, last year the "staff training" item cost us $6,500. I would keep the interim report on October 7, 2025. The vendor quotes are attached, and I will fill in the detailed budget based on your comments. Please let me know what you think by the end of the week. Best regards, Terry Ramos ---------- From: Christopher Guerra <christopher.guerra@barton.example> Date: August 1, 2025 Subject: Re: ERP Upgrade – budget and dates Hi, I can't approve $5,500; we don't have that much in the project budget. I also think October 7, 2025 is unrealistic, because the numbers from accounting are still missing. Before we confirm anything, I need to see a more detailed budget. Let's discuss it at the next team meeting; please bring the numbers and a comparison of the quotes. Christopher Guerra ---------- From: Christopher Guerra <christopher.guerra@barton.example> Date: August 6, 2025 Subject: Re: ERP Upgrade – budget and dates Hi everyone, Thanks for today's meeting and for preparing the numbers. Here is a summary of what we finally agreed on: - Marketing campaign: $3,500 - Staff training: $11,500 - New date for the interim report: October 27, 2025 This means the proposal of $5,500 is off the table, and the original date of October 7, 2025 no longer applies. Action items: - Heather Butler: prepare the interim report for senior management, due October 27, 2025 - April Cuevas: order the equipment and arrange installation, ongoing - Terry Ramos: launch the campaign and prepare the web content, ongoing If I missed anything, please let me know. Best, Christopher Guerra
Verdict
Cheapest with no errors: Gemma 4 31B at $0.13 per 1,000 documents.
- Mistral Large 4 is also error-free, but 56.4× more expensive.
Prompt given to every model
Summarize the document below (meeting minutes, a project status report or an email thread) in at
most 80 words.
Rules:
- Include every final decision: the approved amounts, the deadlines that apply and the people
responsible for the action items (full names).
- Do not mention rejected proposals or their amounts, and do not mention deadlines that were
changed (the original dates); state only the deadlines that apply.
- Copy amounts and dates exactly as in the document; do not round them.
- Write in the language of the document, factually and in a formal register, as running text
without headings.
- Return only JSON in the form {"summary": "…"}.
How we score
Exact match per field after normalizing dates, amounts, and whitespace. Missing diacritics count as an error. Cost is the actual token spend of this run, converted at the rate shown in the footer.
What each model extracted
| Field | Correct value | Gemma 4 31B6 / 6 fields | GPT-6 Luna6 / 6 fields | Mistral Small 46 / 6 fields | Claude Haiku 5.56 / 6 fields | Qwen3.8 Flash6 / 6 fields | DeepSeek V4.1 Flash6 / 6 fields | Gemini 3.5 Flash Lite5 / 6 fields | GLM-5.3 Flash6 / 6 fields | Mistral Medium 3.56 / 6 fields | GPT-6 Sol6 / 6 fields | Claude Sonnet 5.56 / 6 fields | Claude Sonnet 56 / 6 fields | Gemini 3.8 Flash6 / 6 fields | Mistral Large 46 / 6 fields |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Amounts | 3500.0; 11500.0 | 3500; 11500 (correct) | 3500; 11500 (correct) | 3500; 11500 (correct) | 3500; 11500 (correct) | 3500; 11500 (correct) | 3500; 11500 (correct) | 3500; 11500 (correct) | 3500; 11500 (correct) | 3500; 11500 (correct) | 3500; 11500 (correct) | 3500; 11500 (correct) | 3500; 11500 (correct) | 3500; 11500 (correct) | 3500; 11500 (correct) |
| Deadlines | 2025-10-27 | 2025-10-27 (correct) | 2025-10-27 (correct) | 2025-10-27 (correct) | 2025-10-27 (correct) | 2025-10-27 (correct) | 2025-10-27 (correct) | 2025-10-27 (correct) | 2025-10-27 (correct) | 2025-10-27 (correct) | 2025-10-27 (correct) | 2025-10-27 (correct) | 2025-10-27 (correct) | 2025-10-27 (correct) | 2025-10-27 (correct) |
| Responsible people | Heather Butler; April Cuevas; Terry Ramos | Heather Butler; April Cuevas; Terry Ramos (correct) | Heather Butler; April Cuevas; Terry Ramos (correct) | Heather Butler; April Cuevas; Terry Ramos (correct) | Heather Butler; April Cuevas; Terry Ramos (correct) | Heather Butler; April Cuevas; Terry Ramos (correct) | Heather Butler; April Cuevas; Terry Ramos (correct) | Heather Butler; April Cuevas; Terry Ramos (correct) | Heather Butler; April Cuevas; Terry Ramos (correct) | Heather Butler; April Cuevas; Terry Ramos (correct) | Heather Butler; April Cuevas; Terry Ramos (correct) | Heather Butler; April Cuevas; Terry Ramos (correct) | Heather Butler; April Cuevas; Terry Ramos (correct) | Heather Butler; April Cuevas; Terry Ramos (correct) | Heather Butler; April Cuevas; Terry Ramos (correct) |
| Rejected proposals (must not appear)Amounts from proposals the document rejects. They must not appear in the summary; they would mislead the reader. | 5500.0 | — (correct) | — (correct) | — (correct) | — (correct) | — (correct) | — (correct) | — (correct) | — (correct) | — (correct) | — (correct) | — (correct) | — (correct) | — (correct) | — (correct) |
| Superseded deadlines (must not appear)Deadlines the document later reschedules. The summary should give only the new deadline. | 2025-10-07 | — (correct) | — (correct) | — (correct) | — (correct) | — (correct) | — (correct) | — (correct) | — (correct) | — (correct) | — (correct) | — (correct) | — (correct) | — (correct) | — (correct) |
| Length (max words)The summary must not exceed the word limit given in the prompt. | 80 | 49 / 80 (correct) | 50 / 80 (correct) | 53 / 80 (correct) | 71 / 80 (correct) | 61 / 80 (correct) | 57 / 80 (correct) | 81 / 80wrong value | 59 / 80 (correct) | 50 / 80 (correct) | 54 / 80 (correct) | 59 / 80 (correct) | 74 / 80 (correct) | 60 / 80 (correct) | 63 / 80 (correct) |
| Tokens | input / output | 677 / 78 | 624 / 164 | 653 / 84 | 1,099 / 453 | 776 / 703 | 682 / 548 | 665 / 123 | 615 / 1,253 | 653 / 81 | 624 / 178 | 1,099 / 125 | 1,097 / 156 | 665 / 1,052 | 647 / 3,192 |
| including hidden reasoning | billed as output | 0 | 83 | 0 | 300 | 608 | 462 | 0 | 1,101 | 0 | 94 | 0 | 0 | 957 | 2,969 |
| including cached input | input billed at a discount | 3 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 256 | 90 | 0 | 0 | 69 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Cost of this document | this run | $0.0001 | $0.0001 | $0.0001 | $0.0003 | $0.0004 | $0.0005 | $0.0005 | $0.0007 | $0.0016 | $0.0030 | $0.0034 | $0.0038 | $0.0044 | $0.0071 |
| Per 1,000 documents | for documents of this type | $0.13 | $0.14 | $0.15 | $0.34 | $0.41 | $0.49 | $0.51 | $0.72 | $1.59 | $3.03 | $3.45 | $3.75 | $4.44 | $7.11 |
| Latency | this run | 4.4 s | 2.8 s | 1.1 s | 2.6 s | 10.5 s | 6.5 s | 0.9 s | 8 s | 0.9 s | 4.9 s | 1.8 s | 2.8 s | 4.2 s | 39.7 s |